7 Florida Trusts Topics You Need to Know for the Bar Exam

Palm trees silhouetted against a pink and orange sunset sky in Florida.

In this article

If you’re preparing for the Florida Bar Exam, you may be wondering how much time to dedicate to Trusts and which topics deserve the most attention.

Florida Trusts covers a broad range of issues, from creating a valid trust to determining whether creditors can reach trust property. Some rules are straightforward. Others involve distinctions that are easy to overlook, particularly when you’re working through multiple-choice questions.

One useful way to prepare is to review previous Florida Bar Exam essays. Although Trusts has been tested primarily through multiple-choice questions since July 2023, older essays still provide valuable practice with applying Florida law to factual scenarios.

Below are seven Florida Trusts topics worth reviewing, along with relevant statutes and previous exam questions you can use for additional practice.

1. Creating a Valid Trust

What are the requirements for creating a valid trust in Florida?

  • Capacity: The settlor has the capacity to create a trust.
  • Intent: The settlor indicates an intent to create the trust.
  • Beneficiary: The trust has a definite beneficiary, unless it qualifies as a charitable trust, a trust for the care of an animal, or a trust for a noncharitable purpose.
  • Trustee duties: The trustee has duties to perform.
  • Separation of trustee and beneficiary: The same person is not both the sole trustee and sole beneficiary.

A beneficiary is considered definite if the beneficiary can be identified now or in the future, subject to the applicable rule against perpetuities.

A trustee may also be given the power to select a beneficiary from an indefinite class.

For additional practice: Review the February 2022, February 2021, February 2019, July 2013, and July 2012 essays for issues involving the creation of trusts. Focus on whether the statutory requirements for creating a valid trust have been satisfied.

Relevant Florida Statutes: §§ 736.0401–736.0404

Common Trap: A settlor may serve as trustee and beneficiary of the same trust. However, the same person cannot be both the sole trustee and sole beneficiary. Also, don’t assume every trust must be in writing. Florida permits oral trusts in certain circumstances, although their creation and terms must be established by clear and convincing evidence.

2. Revocable vs. Irrevocable Trusts

What is the difference between a revocable and an irrevocable trust in Florida?

Under Florida law, a trust is presumed revocable unless its terms expressly provide that it is irrevocable. This presumption does not apply to trusts created under instruments executed before July 1, 2007.

A revocable trust allows the settlor to amend or revoke the trust. However, the settlor must follow the applicable procedures:

  • If the trust specifies a method: The settlor must substantially comply with that method.
  • If the trust does not specify a method: The settlor may amend or revoke the trust through a later will or codicil that satisfies the statutory requirements, or through another method establishing clear and convincing evidence of the settlor’s intent.

An irrevocable trust generally cannot be amended or revoked unilaterally by the settlor. However, Florida law permits modification or termination under certain circumstances, including through judicial and nonjudicial procedures.

Another important distinction concerns the trustee’s duties. While a trust is revocable, the trustee’s duties are owed exclusively to the settlor, rather than the beneficiaries.

For additional practice: Review the February 2019 Florida Bar Exam essay, which involved a settlor who attempted to revoke a trust orally despite a provision requiring a signed writing. The February 2021 essay addressed a settlor’s creation of a second trust with different distribution provisions.

Relevant Florida Statutes: §§ 736.0601–736.0604

Common Trap: Don’t assume that a settlor can revoke a trust simply by expressing a desire to do so. The February 2019 exam involved a settlor who attempted to revoke a trust by telephone even though the trust specified a signed-writing procedure. Also, don’t assume that an irrevocable trust can never be modified. Florida law provides judicial and nonjudicial methods for changing irrevocable trusts under specified circumstances.

3. Spendthrift and Discretionary Trusts

What is the difference between a spendthrift provision and a discretionary trust?

Although both can protect a beneficiary’s interest from creditors, they operate differently.

A spendthrift provision restricts a beneficiary’s ability to transfer their interest in a trust and prevents most creditors from reaching that interest before distribution. To be valid under Florida law, the provision must restrain both voluntary and involuntary transfers.

However, spendthrift protection is not absolute. Florida law recognizes three exceptions:

  • Support and maintenance: A beneficiary’s child, spouse, or former spouse who has a judgment or court order for support or maintenance.
  • Services protecting a beneficiary’s interest: A judgment creditor who provided services to protect the beneficiary’s interest in the trust.
  • Government claims: Claims by Florida or the United States, to the extent authorized by state or federal law.

For the first two categories, creditors generally must demonstrate that traditional collection methods are insufficient before seeking to attach trust distributions.

A discretionary trust, on the other hand, gives the trustee discretion over whether to make distributions to a beneficiary. Under Florida law, a creditor cannot compel a discretionary distribution or attach the beneficiary’s interest arising from the trustee’s discretion, even if:

  • The trust does not contain a spendthrift provision.
  • The creditor falls within an exception to spendthrift protection.
  • The trustee has abused their discretion.

However, a beneficiary may bring a judicial proceeding against the trustee for abusing that discretion or failing to comply with a distribution standard.

Creditors of the settlor: A separate rule applies when the creditor is pursuing the person who created the trust. During the settlor’s lifetime, property held in a revocable trust remains subject to the settlor’s creditors to the extent it would not otherwise be exempt from creditors’ claims. For an irrevocable trust, a creditor generally may reach the maximum amount that can be distributed to or for the settlor’s benefit.

For additional practice: Review the February 2019 Florida Bar Exam essay, which examined whether a former spouse could collect alimony from a trust containing spendthrift and discretionary provisions. The February 2021 essay involved a beneficiary’s credit card debt and a settlor’s personal creditor. The July 2012 essay tested mandatory versus discretionary distributions and competing creditor claims.

Relevant Florida Statutes: §§ 736.0501–736.0505

Common Trap: Don’t assume that an exception to spendthrift protection allows a creditor to compel a discretionary distribution. The February 2019 and July 2012 Florida Bar Exam essays tested this distinction through claims for alimony or support. Even when a creditor qualifies for an exception to spendthrift protection, the creditor cannot force the trustee to make a distribution that is subject to the trustee’s discretion.

4. Trustee Duties and Powers

What duties and powers does a trustee have under Florida law?

A trustee has a fiduciary responsibility to administer the trust in good faith, consistent with its terms, purposes, the beneficiaries’ interests, and the Florida Trust Code.

A trustee’s principal duties include:

  • Duty of loyalty: The trustee must administer the trust solely in the beneficiaries’ interests and avoid transactions involving conflicts between personal and fiduciary interests.
  • Duty of impartiality: When a trust has multiple beneficiaries, the trustee must act impartially, giving due regard to their respective interests.
  • Duty of prudent administration: The trustee must administer the trust as a prudent person would, exercising reasonable care, skill, and caution.
  • Duty to protect trust property: The trustee must take reasonable steps to control and protect trust assets.
  • Duty to maintain records: The trustee must keep clear and accurate records and maintain trust property separately from personal property.
  • Duty to inform and account: The trustee must keep qualified beneficiaries reasonably informed about the trust and its administration and provide notices, information, and accountings as required by law.

Trustees also have broad powers to manage trust property. Unless restricted by the trust’s terms or applicable law, these powers generally include buying and selling property, making investments, collecting income, managing expenses, and making distributions.

However, the authority to engage in a transaction does not eliminate the trustee’s fiduciary obligations. Every exercise of a trustee’s powers remains subject to the duties imposed by Florida law.

One particularly important issue is self-dealing. A transaction involving trust property that benefits the trustee personally or creates a conflict between the trustee’s personal and fiduciary interests is generally voidable by an affected beneficiary, subject to statutory exceptions.

For example, a transaction may be permitted if the trust expressly authorizes it, the court approves it, or the beneficiary validly consents to or ratifies the transaction.

For additional practice: Review the February 2019 Florida Bar Exam essay, which involved a trustee who purchased trust property for himself and hired his wife to provide accounting services. The July 2013 essay addressed cotrustee succession, trust management responsibilities, and whether a beneficiary’s creditors could reach trust assets when the beneficiary also served as trustee.

Relevant Florida Statutes: §§ 736.0801–736.0817

Common Trap: Don’t assume that a trustee may engage in self-dealing simply because the transaction benefits the trust or the trustee has broad management powers. The February 2019 Florida Bar Exam tested this distinction through a trustee’s purchase of trust property for himself. Under Florida law, a conflicted transaction may be voidable even when the trustee believes the transaction is financially advantageous to the trust.

5. Breach of Trust and Trustee Liability

What happens when a trustee breaches their fiduciary duties?

A breach of trust occurs when a trustee violates a duty owed to a beneficiary.

Examples include using trust property for personal benefit, engaging in prohibited self-dealing, failing to make required distributions, or improperly managing trust assets.

Florida courts have broad authority to remedy a breach of trust, including:

  • Compelling performance: Ordering the trustee to fulfill their duties.
  • Preventing further breaches: Enjoining the trustee from continuing improper conduct.
  • Restoring trust property: Ordering the trustee to return property or pay money to remedy the breach.
  • Requiring an accounting: Ordering the trustee to provide an accounting of trust administration.
  • Suspending or removing the trustee: Restricting or terminating the trustee’s authority.
  • Reducing or denying compensation: Limiting the trustee’s entitlement to payment for their services.

A trustee who commits a breach of trust may also be personally liable for damages. Under Florida law, the trustee is liable for the greater of:

  • The amount necessary to restore the value of the trust property and distributions to what they would have been without the breach, including lost income, capital gains, or appreciation; or
  • The profit the trustee made as a result of the breach.

Another important issue is the effect of an exculpatory clause.

An exculpatory clause is a trust provision that attempts to limit a trustee’s liability for breach of trust. Although Florida permits these provisions, they are unenforceable to the extent they:

  • Relieve the trustee of liability for breaches committed in bad faith or with reckless indifference to the trust’s purposes or beneficiaries’ interests; or
  • Were inserted into the trust instrument through an abuse of a fiduciary or confidential relationship with the settlor.

Additional restrictions apply when the trustee drafted or caused the exculpatory provision to be drafted. In that situation, the trustee must establish that the provision is fair under the circumstances and that its existence and contents were adequately communicated to the settlor or the settlor’s independent attorney, subject to the statute’s effective-date limitation.

For additional practice: Review the February 2019 Florida Bar Exam essay, which involved trustee self-dealing and conflicts of interest. The July 2014 essay examined a trustee who failed to make distributions to a charitable beneficiary while continuing to pay himself, despite an exculpatory clause purporting to eliminate his liability.

Relevant Florida Statutes: § 736.1001, § 736.1002, and § 736.1011

Common Trap: Don’t assume that a trustee’s liability is limited to the amount the trust actually lost. Under Florida law, a trustee who commits a breach of trust may be liable for the greater of the amount necessary to restore the trust to the position it would have occupied without the breach or the profit the trustee made from the breach. This means a trustee may be required to surrender profits even when the trust suffered a smaller financial loss.

6. Modification and Termination of Trusts

Under what circumstances can an irrevocable trust be modified or terminated in Florida?

Although an irrevocable trust generally cannot be changed unilaterally by the settlor, Florida law provides several methods for modifying or terminating a trust.

Judicial modification or termination may be available under the following circumstances:

  • Modification consistent with the settlor’s purpose: A court may modify or terminate an irrevocable trust when its purposes have been fulfilled or become illegal, impossible, wasteful, or impracticable; when unanticipated circumstances would defeat or substantially impair a material purpose; or when a material purpose no longer exists.
  • Modification in the beneficiaries’ best interests: A court may modify an irrevocable trust when compliance with its terms is not in the beneficiaries’ best interests. The court must conform to the settlor’s intent to the extent possible. This authority is subject to statutory exclusions.
  • Correction of mistakes: A court may reform a trust, even if its language is unambiguous, when clear and convincing evidence establishes that a mistake of fact or law affected both the trust’s terms and the accomplishment of the settlor’s intent.

Nonjudicial modification may also be available after the settlor’s death. Under Florida law, the trustee and all qualified beneficiaries may unanimously agree to modify an irrevocable trust without court involvement, subject to statutory limitations.

Importantly, a spendthrift provision or a clause prohibiting amendment or revocation does not, by itself, prevent modification under this procedure.

Termination of an uneconomic trust: A trustee may terminate a trust containing less than $50,000 in property after notifying the qualified beneficiaries if the trustee concludes that the trust’s value does not justify its administrative costs. A court may also modify or terminate a trust when its value is insufficient to justify continued administration, without the same statutory dollar threshold.

For additional practice: Review the February 2022 Florida Bar Exam essay, which involved beneficiaries seeking to modify or terminate an expressly irrevocable trust to receive its assets immediately. The February 2019 essay also addressed termination of a trust following the settlor’s death.

Relevant Florida Statutes: § 736.0410, § 736.04113, § 736.04115, § 736.0412, § 736.0414, § 736.0415

Common Trap: Don’t assume that beneficiaries can modify or terminate an irrevocable trust simply because they agree to receive the assets immediately. The February 2022 exam involved beneficiaries who wanted to change an expressly irrevocable trust’s distribution provisions. Under Florida law, nonjudicial modification requires the unanimous agreement of the trustee and all qualified beneficiaries, and the trust must qualify under the applicable statute. Beneficiary agreement alone does not automatically terminate the trust.

7. Trustee Removal and Compensation

Under what circumstances can a trustee be removed, and how is a trustee compensated?

Florida law establishes specific grounds for removing a trustee. A settlor, cotrustee, or beneficiary may request removal, and a court may also remove a trustee on its own initiative.

A court may remove a trustee when:

  • Serious breach of trust: The trustee has committed a serious breach of their fiduciary duties.
  • Lack of cooperation: Disagreements among cotrustees substantially impair trust administration.
  • Unfitness or failure to administer: The trustee is unfit, unwilling, or persistently fails to administer the trust effectively, and removal best serves the beneficiaries’ interests.
  • Changed circumstances or beneficiary request: A substantial change in circumstances has occurred, or all qualified beneficiaries request removal, provided the court makes the required findings concerning the beneficiaries’ interests, the trust’s material purposes, and the availability of a suitable replacement.

Trustee compensation: If the trust does not specify compensation, the trustee is entitled to reasonable compensation under the circumstances.

If the trust specifies compensation, the court may increase or decrease that amount when:

  • The trustee’s duties are substantially different from those contemplated when the trust was created.
  • The compensation specified in the trust is unreasonably high or low.

A trustee who performs additional services in connection with trust administration may also be entitled to reasonable compensation for those services.

Reimbursement of expenses: A trustee is entitled to reimbursement from trust property for reasonable expenses properly incurred in administering the trust. For example, reasonable accounting expenses incurred in preparing trust tax returns may qualify for reimbursement.

Special rules for attorneys: Florida imposes additional requirements when an attorney who prepares or supervises the execution of a trust instrument is appointed as trustee, or a related person is appointed. For covered appointments, the attorney or related person generally cannot receive trustee compensation unless the statutory disclosure and acknowledgment requirements are satisfied or the statutory family-relationship exception applies.

For additional practice: Review the February 2022 Florida Bar Exam essay, which involved beneficiaries seeking to remove a trustee. The July 2013 essay addressed cotrustee succession and an attorney’s potential appointment as trustee. The July 2012 essay also raised trustee compensation, while the February 2019 essay involved a trustee hiring his wife to provide accounting services.

Relevant Florida Statutes: § 736.0706, § 736.0708, § 736.0709

Common Trap: Don’t assume that beneficiaries must prove a serious breach of trust to obtain a trustee’s removal. Florida law recognizes additional grounds, including substantial changes in circumstances or a unanimous removal request by qualified beneficiaries. However, the court must still determine that removal satisfies the applicable statutory requirements, including protection of the beneficiaries’ interests and consistency with the trust’s material purposes.

How to Practice with Previous Florida Bar Exam Essays

Although Trusts is now primarily tested through multiple-choice questions, previous essays remain useful for understanding how the rules apply.

You can find past questions and selected answers in the Florida Board of Bar Examiners’ study guides.

Start by reading the facts and identifying the Trusts issues. Then, identify  how you would resolve the dispute.

For example, if a question involves a creditor attempting to reach trust property, consider whether the trust contains a spendthrift provision, whether distributions are discretionary, and whether any statutory exceptions apply.

If the question involves trustee misconduct, identify the applicable fiduciary duty, determine whether a breach occurred, and consider the available remedies.

You don’t need to write a complete essay response every time. Focus on recognizing the issues and applying the correct rules.

Final Thoughts

Trusts is a subject where small distinctions can make a significant difference. A revocable trust is not the same as an irrevocable trust. A spendthrift provision operates differently from a discretionary distribution. And a trustee’s authority to manage property does not eliminate their fiduciary duties.

Understanding these distinctions is more useful than simply memorizing definitions.

Use the Florida Trust Code, the current test specifications, and previous exam questions together as you prepare for the Florida Bar Exam.

Looking for additional resources to help with the Bar Exam?

Scroll to Top

Contact Us

Have questions or suggestions?!

Bar Exam Updates & Study Tools

Weekly bar exam updates, study tips, and new resources.