In this article
Imagine you’re preparing for a long voyage from Florida to Tenerife on a massive, three-masted wooden sailing ship. There is no engine—just towering masts, canvas sails, and a crew depending on the wind to get across the Atlantic.
You spend months preparing. You have a checklist: inspect the sails, check the hull, stock enough food and water, and learn the equipment. You carefully work your way through it.
But you never look at what happened when the ship previously made this voyage—or, for that matter, any other voyage.
You depart Florida under clear skies and calm seas. But a few hours into the voyage, the weather changes. Dark clouds gather, and the winds begin to pick up.
Heavy winds tear one of your sails. Rough seas send water across the deck and destroy supplies you failed to secure.
You followed the checklist. What you didn’t understand were the conditions under which everything on that checklist would actually be tested.
That’s where UCC Article 3 comes in.
Studying UCC Article 3 for the Florida Bar Exam
UCC Article 3 is a relatively new addition to the Florida Bar Exam. In 2010, the Florida Supreme Court approved adding UCC Articles 3 and 9 to the subjects tested on the exam, with a two-year period before implementation.
Beginning with the February 2013 Florida Bar Exam, UCC Articles 3 and 9 became tested subjects, and Article 3 subsequently appeared on the essay portion of the exam during several administrations. However, things changed in 2023.
In March 2023, the Florida Board of Bar Examiners published revised test specifications for UCC Articles 3 and 9. Beginning with the July 2023 exam, the Board announced that it would primarily test these subjects through multiple-choice questions.
Those March 2023 specifications remain the most recent test specifications for UCC Article 3.
So, if you’re studying Article 3 today, you have a checklist. You can work through the test specifications and make sure you understand each of the topics Florida identifies.
What About Those Old Article 3 Essays?
When I studied for the Florida Bar Exam, I knew UCC Article 3 was no longer primarily tested through essays. So I largely ignored the old Article 3 essays. I was preparing for multiple choice, and I had limited time.
The problem? There were very few Article 3 multiple-choice questions available to practice.
What I missed was that I didn’t need the old essays to practice writing essays. I could have used them to understand how Florida had tested Article 3.
The test specifications identify the subjects students should study. But knowing that you need to understand negotiable instruments, indorsements, or enforcement is different from recognizing those issues in a complicated factual scenario.
That’s where the historical essays become useful.
They show how Florida has combined different Article 3 concepts in a single problem, what facts made those concepts relevant, and which legal distinctions candidates needed to recognize.
That raised a different question: Even though Article 3 is now tested primarily through multiple-choice questions, can the old essays still help us prepare?
Quick note concerning “primarily”: The FBBE did not say that UCC Article 3 would be tested exclusively through multiple-choice questions. It said Article 3 would be tested primarily through multiple choice. The FBBE may still test Article 3 in the essay portion of the Florida Bar Exam.
Why Look Back to Go Forward?
The old UCC Article 3 essays reveal something important: Florida frequently tested several interconnected legal concepts within a single factual scenario.
Consider the July 2017 essay. A problem involving checks required candidates to consider issues involving indorsements, multiple payees, stop-payment orders, presentment, dishonor, and conversion.
The test specifications identify broader subjects, including checks, negotiation, indorsement, and enforcement. But the essays show how those subjects can interact when applied to actual transactions.
That’s significant. A student might understand the individual rules but struggle to recognize when several of them apply to the same problem.
The historical essays help bridge that gap.
The real value of these old essays isn’t in practicing essay writing. It’s in what they can teach us about how Florida tests Article 3. They’re useful for three different reasons:
- They show us how legal concepts interact. A single transaction can raise issues involving negotiability, negotiation, enforcement, and defenses. The historical essays illustrate how those concepts work together.
- They show us how Florida tests what is on the checklist. The specifications identify subjects such as negotiable instruments, checks, promissory notes, indorsements, and enforcement. The essays show how Florida has applied those subjects to specific factual scenarios.
- They let us look for patterns. When the same concepts, distinctions, or types of problems appear across multiple exams, we can identify areas Florida has historically emphasized. That doesn’t predict what will appear on a future exam, but it provides useful context for studying.
For multiple-choice preparation, all three are useful. If you can work through the Article 3 issues Florida built into these essays and understand why the rules apply, you’ll have a stronger foundation for recognizing those same issues when Florida puts them into a multiple-choice fact pattern.
So, what did Florida actually test?
What Has Florida Actually Tested?
The released Florida Bar Exam essays dating back to UCC Article 3’s addition to the exam include four that tested Article 3: February 2016, July 2017, February 2018, and February 2019. Rather than focusing on how candidates were expected to structure their essay answers, the analysis below examines the substance: what happened in each problem and the specific Article 3 concepts candidates needed to know.
A quick note before we dive in: Several of these essays tested UCC Article 3 alongside Article 9 and other subjects. We’re not attempting to summarize everything tested in each essay. We’re extracting the Article 3 concepts because that’s what we’re trying to understand here.
February 2019
What It Dealt With: A business executed a promissory note to obtain a $50,000 loan and later defaulted on its payments. The lender sought to enforce the promissory note and recover the unpaid balance.
Key Concepts Tested: Promissory notes; the maker’s obligation to pay; enforcement following default; and potential acceleration of the unpaid balance.
What This Essay Illustrates: How enforcement of a promissory note can arise alongside a secured creditor’s remedies under Article 9.
February 2018
What It Dealt With: A bank acquired a mortgage loan, including an assignment of the promissory note, but later lost the original note. After the borrowers stopped making payments, the bank sought to enforce its rights despite being unable to produce the original instrument.
Key Concepts Tested: Promissory notes; transfer and assignment of instruments; persons entitled to enforce an instrument; and enforcement of a lost instrument.
What This Essay Illustrates: How the transfer of a promissory note and the subsequent loss of the original instrument can raise separate questions about a party’s right to enforce the obligation.
July 2017
What It Dealt With: Two check transactions created separate Article 3 problems. One involved a cashier’s check that was indorsed to Debbie and that First Bank refused to honor after the purchaser attempted to stop payment. The other involved a personal check payable to “Debbie Debtor, Carlos Consignor” that Debbie indorsed and cashed without Carlos’s signature.
Key Concepts Tested: Checks and cashier’s checks; negotiation and indorsement; instruments payable to multiple payees; stop-payment orders; presentment and dishonor; bank obligations on cashier’s checks; and potential claims involving warranties and conversion.
What This Essay Illustrates: How two check transactions can raise interconnected issues involving negotiation, indorsement, payment obligations, and the rights of different parties to an instrument.
February 2016
What It Dealt With: Sam used his thumbprint to sign both a promissory note and a check. The note required him to pay $15,000 or, if he could not timely pay, provide title and keys to his Porsche. The note was later given as a gift to Broker’s nephew. Separately, Broker indorsed Sam’s $25,000 check to a check-cashing company, after which Sam attempted to stop payment.
Key Concepts Tested: Promissory notes and checks; signatures by thumbprint; requirements of negotiability; instruments payable in money; negotiation and indorsement; transfer by gift; holder-in-due-course status; value and notice; and personal and real defenses.
What This Essay Illustrates: How the negotiability of an instrument affects the rights of subsequent transferees, the availability of holder-in-due-course protection, and the defenses that may be asserted against enforcement.
What Should You Do Next?
If you’re studying UCC Article 3 for the Florida Bar Exam, start with the current test specifications. But don’t stop there.
Take a look at the four released Article 3 essays: February 2016, July 2017, February 2018, and February 2019. You don’t need to write them as practice essays. Instead, work through the Article 3 issues and see whether you can identify the rules Florida expected candidates to recognize. Ask yourself: if Florida turned this issue into a multiple-choice question, would I recognize it?
As always, when reviewing older essays, compare the concepts tested with the most recent test specifications. The specifications can change over time, and you want to make sure you’re focusing your preparation on the subjects Florida currently identifies for testing.
The checklist tells you what to pack. The old essays show you what others encountered along the way.
The Checklist Is Only the Beginning
If you’re preparing for a long voyage, you should still use the checklist. You just shouldn’t ignore what happened on the voyages that came before yours.
The same is true for UCC Article 3. Start with the test specifications. Learn what Florida tells you to learn. But then look at how Florida has actually tested those concepts, how different rules interact within the same problem, and which facts made those rules relevant.
We can’t know exactly what conditions we’ll encounter on exam day. But we can learn something from the voyages that came before us.